Who Should I Start? DK Metcalf or Wan'Dale Robinson

Friday, September 5, 7:07 PM

Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf will get his first game action with the team in a Week 1 road matchup against the New York Jets. Metcalf is coming off his least productive campaign since his rookie season, though he still averaged an impressive 15 yards per catch in 2024. Now with a new contract and a new quarterback, Metcalf will hope to re-establish himself as a true WR1. This won't be an easy task, however, against a New York defense that ranked top-10 last season in receptions, yards, touchdowns, and fantasy points allowed to receivers. Still, Metcalf's potential target volume is tough to overlook given Pittsburgh's lack of depth at the position. While an explosive outing is relatively unlikely, Metcalf is a viable WR2 or flex play in most fantasy leagues this week.

Saturday, September 6, 1:37 AM

New York Giants wide receiver Wan'Dale Robinson is a risky Week 1 fantasy play despite a career-high 140 targets in 2024. He enters the season with new quarterback Russell Wilson, and he is ranked as the 57th-best fantasy wide receiver for Week 1. The matchup against the Washington Commanders does not appear favorable, as they were the 8th-ranked fantasy defense against wide receivers in 2024 by allowing an average of 30.24 points per game. Robinson's specific role as a smaller slot receiver might limit his upside. With a career-long average of just 8.2 yards per reception, his fantasy value is heavily reliant on short, high-volume passes. This makes him a risky Flex option, as his floor is dependent on receptions and his ceiling is limited by his role in the offense.