Who Should I Start? Justin Tucker or Matt Gay

Monday, September 18, 9:59 AM

Baltimore Ravens kicker Justin Tucker delivered a better fantasy performance in the Week 2 win over the Bengals. He knocked down all three of his extra points while making two out of his three field goal attempts. The only one he missed was a 59-yarder that went wide-right. He did, however, convert on a 44 and 40-yarder. Tucker remains one of the elite options at kicker and he gave fantasy managers at least a double-digit performance in Week 2 after a lower-scoring effort in Week 1. He'll still be at the top of the position choices heading into Week 3 against the Colts.

Monday, September 11, 12:45 AM

Indianapolis Colts kicker Matt Gay hit all three of his extra-point attempts in Sunday's 31-21 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars. The 29-year-old didn't see the first field-goal try with his new team in his Indianapolis debut, but he did his job when called upon Sunday. Gay has been an accurate kicker for his career, burying 86-of-94 FGs (91.5%) since 2020. But fantasy managers may be able to find a stronger choice on waiver wires, as the former Pro Bowler's offense may not be the most reliable unit in 2023. Gay will kick indoors during Week 2's date with the division-rival Houston Texans, but it projects as a low-scoring affair.