Who Should I Start? Tua Tagovailoa or Caleb Williams

Friday, September 12, 9:02 PM

Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa will be looking to bounce back after a brutal Week 1 when the Dolphins host the Patriots in Week 2. Coach Mike McDaniel and General Manager Chris Grier have come under fire after the team's brutal 33-8 loss in Indianapolis during Week 1, and change could be on the horizon if Tagovailoa can't turn things around. He only completed 14 of 23 pass attempts for 114 yards and a late touchdown. He threw a pair of bad interceptions and was sacked three times, also losing a fumble. The entire offense seemed completely out of sorts, with timing that was off and shaky pass protection. He was one of the lowest-scoring fantasy quarterbacks in Week 1, and even in a favorable matchup against the Patriots, he's only the No. 26 QB in the RotoBaller rankings for Week 2. Even in two-quarterback leagues, there are probably stronger options available.

Friday, September 12, 11:04 PM

Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams is coming off a strong fantasy performance, completing 21 of 35 passes for 210 yards and a touchdown while adding six carries for 58 yards and another score on the ground. Despite Chicago's tough loss to the Minnesota Vikings, Williams showcased his dual-threat ability and the kind of upside that can make him a valuable fantasy asset. In Week 2, Williams draws the Detroit Lions, a defense he thrived against in 2024, averaging 24 fantasy points across two meetings. With head coach Ben Johnson making his return to Detroit, the atmosphere at Ford Field will be intense, but Williams' rushing floor keeps him in play. Consider him a high-end QB2 this week and a must-start in Superflex formats.