Who Should I Start? Josh Reynolds or Quentin Johnston

Saturday, September 27, 7:24 PM

New York Jets wide receiver Josh Reynolds will head into Week 4's contest with the Miami Dolphins sans an injury designation after back-to-back full practices. Reynolds missed the previous two weeks after picking up a hamstring injury leading up to the team's Week 2 loss to Buffalo, but he's ready to rock for an excellent matchup with the Dolphins. Quarterback Justin Fields will also make his return after missing time with a concussion, so New York's offense is on an upward trajectory as they return to health. Miami's defense doesn't present as a difficult test, so it's a good chance for the Jets to shake off any remaining rust as they enter mid-season form. However, the Texas native's ceiling is capped playing across from target hog teammate Garrett Wilson in a run-centric attack. If the offense ever decides to open it up through the air, Reynolds could be an interesting low-end PPR option. For now, he's better left alone for fantasy purposes.

Tuesday, September 30, 12:42 AM

Los Angeles Chargers wide receiver Quentin Johnston was one of the few bright spots in the team's 21-18 loss to the New York Giants on Sunday. He continued to deliver, leading the team with eight catches on 13 targets for 98 yards while scoring his fourth touchdown of the season. Johnston is now the WR3 overall in PPR formats, becoming the breakout star fantasy managers hoped for when he was drafted in the first round in 2023. His size and downfield ability make him Justin Herbert's top big-play target so far this season. Johnston now faces a Washington Commanders' defense that has struggled against the pass, setting up another big opportunity for the wideout. With consistent volume and scoring upside, Johnston should be treated as a strong WR2 with WR1 potential in Week 5.