Joe Burrow Fantasy Season Over: Grade 3 Turf Toe Injury Impact

Joe Burrow suffered a devastating Grade 3 turf toe injury during Week 2 against Jacksonville and underwent surgery on September 19, effectively ending his 2025 fantasy season. The Cincinnati Bengals quarterback faces a 3+ month recovery timeline, with the earliest possible return in Week 17, creating massive ripple effects across fantasy leagues.

This is a crushing blow to fantasy managers who invested a top-5 quarterback pick in Burrow. Through two games before the injury, he was averaging just 7.93 fantasy points per game, a stark contrast to his elite 21.93 points per game in 2024 when he threw for 4,918 yards and 43 touchdowns. The injury occurred after Burrow had already absorbed five sacks in just two games, highlighting the offensive line concerns that may have contributed to this setback.

Fantasy Impact

Burrow's injury creates immediate roster decisions across all formats. In redraft leagues, he becomes an immediate drop candidate, freeing up valuable bench space for streaming options or handcuff running backs. Dynasty managers face a more complex decision, as Burrow's long-term outlook remains strong despite this being his third major injury in five seasons.

The ripple effects extend beyond Burrow himself. Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins face significant target quality downgrades with Jake Browning taking over at quarterback. Browning went 4-3 in seven starts during Burrow's 2023 wrist injury, but fantasy production for skill position players was notably diminished. Based on current PPR rankings, both Chase and Higgins should be downgraded by at least one tier.

The Bengals have added veteran quarterbacks Mike White and Sean Clifford to the practice squad, providing additional depth behind Browning. However, neither represents a significant upgrade for fantasy purposes. The team's favorable remaining schedule includes eight games against defenses allowing 29+ points per game, potentially keeping Cincinnati competitive but limiting ceiling outcomes for fantasy assets.

DFS players should completely fade Bengals offensive stacks for the remainder of the season, while season-long managers must pivot to streaming quarterback options. The injury also impacts betting markets, with Cincinnati's Super Bowl odds plummeting from 20-to-1 to 80-to-1.

Next Steps

Immediate action items include dropping Burrow in redraft leagues and exploring waiver wire quarterback options. Monitor Browning's early performances to gauge whether Chase and Higgins remain startable WR2/WR3 options or require benching in favor of more reliable alternatives.

Dynasty managers should hold Burrow but temper expectations for 2026, as turf toe injuries can have lingering effects on mobility and comfort in the pocket. Track his rehabilitation progress through December, as any setbacks could push his return into the 2026 season. The earliest realistic fantasy relevance would be Week 17, making him irrelevant for most playoff-bound teams.

Filed under: Free Articles